Then found a book of newspaper extracts that proved that not only did Don Bartholomew survive his wife (not right for my Anna's second husband), but he also died after Anna had remarried her second husband. Ok, so not him.
Back to the census drawing board. I came up with another candidate: Russell Bartholomew. (He was in the 1830 census and not in the 1840 census, and appeared to be the right age.) Issue - he wasn't in Mentor Twp. To a map! He lived in Concord Twp, which is right next to Mentor Twp in Geauga Co, Ohio. Less of a issue. Larger problem: He is a young, newly married man in the 1830 census! His wife remarried in 1832! I posit that they had a child, named David. But none of David's records name his parents. The book of newspaper extracts had an entry for Russell Bartholomew giving his death in January 1831. This is all leading to Russell looking like a good candidate.
Looking at the 1830 census, I then went to the neighbors. Russell and his young wife were living next to an older man named Jedediah Bartholomew. Perhaps Russell's father? Went looking for family trees online to see if anyone had done anything on the family. Well, a little bit - I found trees but they only had two children. Then it is time to Google.
I found a post from 2006 on an Ancestry message board about New Jersey Rev. War veterans that mentioned a Bartholomew book from 1885 - "Record of the Bartholomew Family."
And there is Russell, marrying Anna Richardson and having one son, David. And Russell's father is Jedediah.
Of course, there are no sources or citations in this family history. So I still have work to do. Russell and Anna's marriage is not in indexes for Geauga Co, Ohio. It may be that they married in New York before coming to Ohio. (Of course, early New York vital records are fairly scarce.)
So while I still have work to do, I know have at least one source (however secondary and/or derivative) that confirms my hypothesis that Anna Richardson married, first, Russell Bartholomew, and had one son, David Bartholomew (Civil War veteran). She then married, second, as his third wife, Otis Harrington, and had four more children.
Genealogy happy dance!
|Title page of the Record of the Bartholomew Family, published 1885.|